Cary Hegreberg, Published December 28 2013
Letter: Good ol’ days really not so goodDuring my annual hunting pilgrimage back home to northwestern North Dakota in October, I was struck by opinions about how oil development activity has affected families and communities. Clearly, landowners and their descendants who possess mineral rights on farmland are benefiting immensely from a financial windfall. Others are selling gravel and even water to the various companies that build facilities, frack wells, etc.
Others, however, bemoan the remarkable change and the impacts oil development is creating. Many gravel roads are in deplorable condition as steady streams of industrial trucks meet each other, with drivers praying they do not slip off into the muck. I witnessed a traffic jam in remote Fortuna, N.D., as a paving crew worked on Highway 5 and a line of oil-related trucks attempted to both enter and exit the highway at the junction of a county road. Five years ago, a person could sit in the middle of that intersection eating lunch and would not be bothered by traffic.
This sudden surge of people, vehicles, inconvenience and problems has some people in the area craving “the good ol’ days.” A neighboring farmer told me, “I just want things to go back the way they were.” As I drove out of his yard and across rural roads in search of pheasant hunting spots, the ruins of old farmsteads I’d driven past many times before took on new meaning.
Is this what some people wanted to go back to? Are the “good old days” when perfectly good homes and outbuildings were shuttered because the elderly occupants died or moved to town? Were things really better when school after school, in town after town, closed and consolidated – and rural churches closed by the dozen because the congregations could no longer support a pastor?
There are more abandoned schools and churches in Divide County than there are functional ones. Indeed, there are probably more abandoned homes than occupied ones – and that does not include the ones torn down or burned. The truth is the Northern Plains area of western North Dakota, South Dakota and eastern Montana had been bleeding population since the 1960s.
The region is littered with virtual ghost towns that had been on life support for decades. Communities like Alkabo, Ambrose and Alamo are anchored by prominent, once-proud but long-vacant high schools that graduated students who trudged off to college or jobs in the city. For decades, people like me have come back home mostly to hunt or attend funerals.
In recent years, local and state governments, along with rural cooperatives and brave local investors, had poured millions of dollars into ill-fated economic development projects like pasta plants, hog-feeding operations and other value-added ag processing ventures. While a few success stories exist, they were mostly desperate attempts to create a few decent jobs that could allow a handful of young people to stay in the community.
Thanks to the oil boom, the abandoned pasta plant at Crosby, N.D., is now a truck stop, complete with tire repair, diesel mechanics, and farm supply store. Ten years ago, you could have bought most any house in town for $25,000, with many sitting vacant. Today, Crosby is annexing land for new subdivisions; school enrollment is increasing for the first time in decades.
Even Williston, which had maintained a population of about 14,000 for years because people from the adjoining rural areas moved there when they got too old to feed cows or plow snow on the farm, is growing at a faster pace than ever before. For most of the area known as “the Bakken,” the alternative to oil development was a slow, steady downward economic spiral as technology made farming and agricultural services more efficient and less labor intensive.
It’s a godsend
As a Montana resident who represents industrial construction firms, recent development in the Oil Patch has been a godsend. Many Montana companies are earning revenues, paying wages and health insurance to their Montana workers, and paying taxes, when they would have otherwise gone out of business or dramatically downsized. Montana contractors are working for private oil and pipeline companies, railroads, real estate developers, and for public owners like local and state governments trying to catch up with infrastructure deficiencies.
Energy development spells jobs, economic opportunity and prosperity, often for communities that were destined for eventual ghost town status. Homes now have value when the former residents retire or die. Local youths can find jobs in their hometowns. Communities have a tax base to support a respectable quality of life.
While change and inconvenience are everyday occurrences due to the oil boom, going back to the way things used to be – stagnant development and out-migration – will not create the future of vibrant communities we see ahead of us.
Hegreberg, is executive director of the Montana chapter of the Associated General Contractors of America and is a graduate of Divide County (N.D.) High School.