Chuck Haga, Forum News Service, Published September 07 2013
Appeals court: Yankton out
“This is it,” said Erich Longie, a Spirit Lake elder and organizer of a petition drive to oust Yankton, who was elected chairman in early 2012. “It’s over, and we’re celebrating.”
In a supervisory writ issued Friday, the Northern Plains Intertribal Court of Appeals in Aberdeen, S.D., overturned the tribal court’s July 16 decision that had dismissed a recall petition against Yankton and ordered him reinstated.
Yankton was ceremoniously reinstated the next day in a gathering of supporters, but members of the Tribal Council sought and obtained a stay of that action. The tribal court later issued a restraining order prohibiting the former chairman from entering tribal headquarters or having contact with tribal officials.
Yankton could not be reached for comment Saturday.
He continues to press his case for reinstatement in U.S. District Court in Grand Forks, where he seeks relief from the tribal court’s restraining order, claiming he is a virtual prisoner on the reservation and unable to conduct the tribe’s business as chairman.
Yankton’s opponents last week filed a motion to dismiss with the federal court, arguing in part that the court has no jurisdiction in a sovereign tribal matter.
The recall petition seeking Yankton’s ouster was circulated after earlier attempts to remove him by votes, first by an elders meeting and later at an “emergency general assembly,” were deemed to violate the tribe’s constitution.
After the assembly vote, Leander “Russ” McDonald was named chairman, but he later conferred with Yankton and agreed that the constitution required a recall petition and vote by the membership.
The petition was circulated and presented to the Spirit Lake Election Board, which validated sufficient signatures to force a recall meeting, which Tribal Vice Chairman Joel Red Fox called on July 1. At that meeting, members recalled Yankton and elected McDonald to replace him.
Appeals court connection
Yankton, however, appealed to the Election Board and presented more names that he said should have been struck from the recall petition, which required signers to be members of the tribe and living on the reservation. More names were removed, leaving a total short of what was required, and Yankton used that result to persuade the Tribal Court to invalidate the petition and reinstate him as chairman.
When McDonald and others appealed to the Aberdeen court, Yankton argued that the tribe had left the appeals court last year, so it lacked jurisdiction. But in its order Friday, the appeals court found that Spirit Lake’s withdrawal last year was not done according to Spirit Lake law, as it was not ratified at a general assembly.
“Accordingly … the NPICA is the designated appellate court of the Spirit Lake Tribe and Yankton’s motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction is denied.”
The appeals court held further that the Tribal Court’s order ruling the recall petition invalid and reinstating Yankton “was error” because it exceeded authority granted by the tribe’s constitution to involve itself in a recall process.
McDonald also was unavailable for comment, and it’s unclear whether he will resume the chairmanship. He has been serving as the Fort Totten District representative on the Tribal Council.
Yankton and his opponents have agreed on one thing: While the leadership controversy continues, the tribe is handicapped in responding to pressing issues, including the ongoing effort to rebuild its child protection services.
Darren Walking Eagle, who had been chief administrative officer of the tribe under Yankton until he was released this summer — “for lack of funds,” he said — faulted the continuing uncertainty for hurting the tribal government’s ability to operate programs, secure grants and otherwise serve the people of Spirit Lake.
Still work to do
Longie said his Facebook page “lit up (Friday) night with people thanking me. They’re very happy” that the legal fight, at least, appears to be over.
“And now that this is over, I think we’re going to be able to move forward,” he said. “We still have a lot of work to do.”
Longie said McDonald and the Fort Totten District took one action last week aimed at bolstering Spirit Lake’s effort to address problems of sexual abuse, including the sexual abuse of children. A display case that held photographs of more than two dozen registered sex offenders living on the reservation had been removed from the tribal government building last year by Yankton. District representatives declared last week it should be returned to the tribe’s central gathering place.
One looming task will be reconciliation.
“The anger, the resentment created by this are going to go on for a long time,” Longie said.