Don Davis and Danielle Nordine, State Capitol Bureau, Published March 09 2012
Want to bet on pull tabs funding stadium?ST. PAUL – Funding stadium construction with pull-tab and bingo revenue may not be a safe bet.
A professor who has studied the issue said predicting the impact that changing state law would have on pull tab and bingo revenue is chancy.
And the organization representing charities that sponsor pull-tab and bingo games in establishments across the state said the proposal to allow electronic devices does not go far enough to convince local charities to convert.
In an effort to convince charities to back a Vikings stadium financing proposal, Gov. Mark Dayton and Revenue Commissioner Myron Frans on Friday announced a new plan that would increase charities’ profits on the two games.
Executive Director King Wilson of Allied Charities of Minnesota was not convinced that charities would go along with the idea.
Without the charities’ support, passing an already controversial stadium-funding plan becomes more difficult. The e-pull-tab idea appears to be the most acceptable among legislators.
Dayton leans toward allowing electronic pull tabs because another leading gambling proposal, adding casinos at horse-racing tracks, likely would be tied up in court for years.
The stadium bill would fund the state’s $398 million portion of a $975 million Vikings stadium by selling bonds to be repaid with revenue from newly allowed electronic pulltab and bingo devices.
The theory for the plan is that allowing patrons to play on electronic devices would attract more business than the current paper games. Charities for years have said that authorizing electronic devices, a bit like playing on an iPad, would bring more money to them, the host bars and, via taxes, the state.
The state Gambling Control Board and Revenue Department estimate electronic pull tabs and bingo would bring $62.5 million in new money to each the state and charities, with $28 million more to host businesses, such as bars.
Estimates released Friday show large gains in profits from charities that host games.
In Moorhead, the Moorhead Youth Hockey Association is one of the largest pull-tab beneficiaries in the state. Its $4.8 million in current pull-tab receipts ranks 16th among about 1,200 organizations statewide that use charitable gambling, and its $216,000 in pull-tab profits rank eighth.
Under the new state projections, both of those figures would more than double. The state says it expects the organization to turn $524,000 in profits on $11.2 million in total business under the new system.
The state also projects big windfalls for the local American Legion and Veterans of Foreign Wars posts. The VFW currently takes in $1.6 million in receipts and turns $49,000 in profits. Under state projections, those figures would rise to $4.4 million and $191,000 respectively.
The Legion, which makes $77,000 in profits on
$1.5 million in business, would do $195,000 in profits and $3.9 million in receipts, according to the state.
Gaming managers at all three organizations could not be reached by The Forum for comment on Friday.
An economist who watches gambling finances wonders about the estimates.
St. Thomas University professor John Spry said it is impossible to predict how much more, or less, could be spent if electronic pull-tab and bingo games are allowed.
The estimates could be high or low, he said.
When the state estimates a new type of revenue, it usually is based on existing sales, income or whatever is being taxed. The professor said there is no way to know how customers would react to a new form of gambling.
“I would suggest to lawmakers that they very, very carefully look at” the proposal, he said.
E-pull-tab supporters say Minnesotans are eager to try the electronic devices.
“There’s a tech-savvy crowd out there, and it isn’t just young people,” Wilson said.
Allied Charities board member Genny Hinnenkamp, who works with Duluth’s Irving Community Club, said customers have asked for electronic gaming options.
She said paper pull tabs likely still would be offered for those who want to play the traditional way, and also could offer backup if electronic machines fail or are all being used.
No one can predict how popular electronic pull tabs and bingo would be in the future, Spry said, so a backup financing plan makes sense.
The stadium bill does not contain a backup.
House bill sponsor Rep. Morrie Lanning, R-Moorhead, said he is confident the Revenue Department and Gambling Control Board did a good job estimating revenue. He said the bill is also written to bring in more money than is needed, allowing a reserve to build up if there are lean years.
Before Friday, stadium supporters planned on
$72 million a year from
e-pull tabs, but Dayton said that in order to get charities to support the plan the new proposal reduces taxes on charities by $10 million, which lowers the state take by that amount.
It appeared to Wilson, leader of charities that rely on pull-tab and bingo proceeds, that tax cuts for charities in the new plan are well under half what they wanted in legislation introduced before charitable gambling was tied to stadium financing.
“With this modest tax reduction and rate I don’t know that we are going to see the charities jump on this,” Wilson said.
Lanning and Frans said charities should like the large increase in profits the Revenue Department projects.
“It strikes me that there are some pretty impressive numbers for additional revenue that the charities would generate and additional revenues that the bars (that host the games) would generate,” Lanning said. “I think they would be making a mistake” to dismiss the proposal.
However, Lanning said, the stadium bill cannot move forward unless it appears charities will buy into the electronic device plan.
E-pull tab, bingo highlights
Some key provisions in a plan released Friday by the Dayton administration to allow electronic pull tabs and bingo revenue to fund a Vikings stadium:
<•> $62.5 million more gambling taxes, up from $37 million annually now collected
<•> $62.5 million more profit for charities that sponsor the games, up from $44 million
<•> $28 million more for bars that host charitable gambling, up from $18 million
<•> Gambling taxes would fall 14 percent
<•> Paper pulltabs and bingo could continue, even in bars that opt for electronic devices
<•> Electronic devices would be an option for operators of the 1,200 charitable gambling organizations at 2,800 sites
– Dayton administration
Have a comment to share about a story? Letters to the editor should include author’s name, address and phone number. Generally, letters should be no longer than 250 words. All letters are subject to editing. Send a letter to the editor.
Forum reporter Marino Eccher contributed to this report
Don Davis reports for Forum Communications Co.