Scott Wente, Published April 21 2009
Coleman files election appealST. PAUL – Norm Coleman wants the state’s highest court to reverse his U.S. Senate election loss.
The former Republican senator appealed to the Minnesota Supreme Court on Monday, hoping it will overturn a special judicial panel’s ruling that declared Democrat Al Franken the winner.
Coleman’s key claim is that the disparate ways absentee ballots were handled by local election officials in the Nov. 4 election violated the U.S. Constitution. He argues that that problem was not corrected during a recent election trial and there remain ballots to count.
The trial ended with the judges declaring that Franken won 312 more votes than Coleman out of more than 2.9 million votes cast.
“We do believe that the district court got it wrong on the law,” Coleman attorney Ben Ginsberg said. “Their decision disenfranchises many Minnesotans.”
An appeal is part of the state election contest process, but Franken attorney Marc Elias said Coleman has presented his arguments to judges and state election officials multiple times with no success.
“What we have now is the death throes of the Coleman legal effort,” Elias said.
But Ginsberg said the Supreme Court has “a broader view of the law,” so can consider constitutional issues that the three-judge panel did not fully explore.
Among Coleman’s complaints is that similar absentee ballots were treated differently in different counties – some were counted, others rejected – and that the lack of a statewide standard violates the Constitution’s mandate that states cannot deny any person “equal protection of the laws.”
Coleman also will ask the state Supreme Court to decide whether the trial court should not have allowed votes from a Franken-leaning Minneapolis precinct to be part of the tally even though the ballots are missing.
The high court request comes more than five months after the election. Coleman entered a statewide recount last November leading Franken by 215 votes. The recount ended with Franken on top by 225 votes.
Wente works for Forum Communications Co., which owns The Forum. He can be reached at (651) 290-0707 or firstname.lastname@example.org